Dinosaur-Killer was Soft on Algae
A view of the sea cliff at Stevns Klint, Denmark.
Credit: R. Summons
The asteroid impact that many researchers claim was the cause of the dinosaur die-off was bad news for marine life at the time as well. But new research shows that microalgae – one of the primary producers in the ocean – bounced back from the global extinction in about 100 years or less.
Most of the research on the Cretaceous-Paleogene (K-P) extinction event, previously called the Cretaceous-Tertiary (K-T) event, has involved charting the loss of organisms that had bones or shells.
"But there were many organisms in the ocean that left us no hard fossils," says Julio Sepúlveda of MIT.
Sepúlveda and his colleagues study the molecular remains of microorganisms. They have recently extracted some of these organic residues from rocks dated to the K-P extinction. The results, reported in this week’s issue of the journal Science, show that ocean algae community greatly shrunk in size but only for about a century.
"We found that primary production in this part of the ocean recovered extremely rapidly after the impact," Sepúlveda says.
A full recovery of the ocean ecosystem probably took perhaps a million years or so, but the quick rebound of photosynthesizing algae seems to confirm models that suggest the impact delivered a swift, abrupt blow to the Earth’s environment.
The hallmark of the K-P extinction 65 million years ago is the complete disappearance of non-avian dinosaurs. As for the cause, geologic evidence incriminates a meteorite that landed off of the Yucatan peninsula – although some debate continues over just how lethal this impact was.
The Fish Clay at Stevns Klint is the dark brownish band running along the middle of the cliff face. Below is chalk from the Cretaceous period, while above is limestone from the Paleogene period.
Credit: J. Sepúlveda
Debris from the impact would have darkened the sky for several years, shutting down photosynthesis across the planet. But just how long plants and algae were deprived of sunlight has been hard to say. The fossil record is not very clear on this issue, which is why some scientists are looking for other biological clues.
"We study the ‘invisible life’ – the microorganisms that don’t show up in the fossil record but who were extremely important in turning over carbon in the ancient ocean," says co-author Roger Summons, also from MIT.
When marine life dies, it falls to the bottom of the sea, where much of its corpse is degraded by bacteria and geochemical processing. But some pieces of biomolecules resist degradation, especially in areas where oxygen levels are low.
This organic detritus can in time accumulate into "fossil fuels," like petroleum and natural gas. In specific cases, researchers are able to extract these molecular leftovers from ancient rock and identify their chemical structure.
"The trick is figuring out what makes what," Summons says.
For example, plant algae make a lot of lipids – specifically sterols like the cholesterol found in humans. In ocean sediments, algae sterols break down, leaving a chemical "skeleton" called a sterane.
Steranes and other biomarkers have been isolated from ancient rocks, thus providing information on what microorganisms were living in past epochs of Earth’s history.
This technique has so far not revealed much on the K-P event, but Sepúlveda and Summons and their colleagues have made headway thanks to high-resolution mass spectrometry and some prime samples from the Fiskeler (a.k.a. Fish Clay) in Stevns Klint, Denmark.
The Fish Clay – a roughly 40-centimeter-wide layer in a seaside cliff – is a classic example of the geological ground zero of the K-P extinction event. Below is the dinosaur-filled Cretaceous period, while above is the dinosaur-free Paleogene period.
This particular boundary layer, which formed in shallow water of about 100 meters in depth, is much thicker than at other places around the world, so Sepúlveda and his colleagues were able to document several thousand years of the K-P event in short 150-year-long time-steps.
|A close-up view of the 40-centimeter-wide Fish Clay boundary layer.
Credit: J. Sepúlveda
In each time-step, the researchers isolated steranes and other organic molecules called hopanes. Hopanes, which come predominantly from bacteria, provide a kind of baseline, since their contribution remained relatively constant over the extinction time period.
"It’s hard to imagine microorganisms such as bacteria suffering very much, since they can eat almost anything," Sepúlveda says.
However, a dip in sterane levels right after the meteorite hit is evidence of an algae die-off. Fortunately for these tiny plants, the worst of it was over in about 100 years.
But are these results representative of the whole ocean? Previous studies had found that life in the deep ocean didn’t recuperate from the meteorite for millions of years.
"The signal from the Danish Fish Clay seems at odds with the oceanic signals," says Henk Brinkhuis of Utrecht University in the Netherlands. "One explanation might be that the Danish sections represent relatively marginal marine settings where regionally a lot of food and dead material was around, likely different from the true blue ocean."
However, another possibility is that the surface ocean really did recover rather quickly, but for some reason a lot less organic material sank to the deep ocean. This would make more sense with models of the meteorite impact that predict sunlight would be blocked out for only ten years or so.
"Once the sunlight comes back, there’s really nothing we can think of to hold down the primary production," says Steven D’Hondt of the University of Rhode Island. "These microorganisms only need a few nutrients and some light to survive."
The rapid recovery of algae may have also been better for other marine species.
"You can’t support a very complex ecosystem with just bacteria," Summons says.